Greer on feisy broads
Luis Bunuel's Belle de Jour (1967) "has a reputation for being one of the sexiest films ever made, simply because Catherine Deneuve behaves throughout like a pre-adolescent girl. Through the prism of the 21st century, the film seems oddly contrived; what is now a cliche -- the child who, subjected to the sexual advances of an adult, then becomes a frigid woman who is only turned on by squalor -- is coyly exploited as a series of fetishistic images that juxtapose her fantasy life with her actual life.
"As Severine Serizy, Deneuve moves through the imagery of what are meant to be her own fantasies like a sleepwalker. By her own account, Bunuel could not relate to her at all and never told her what he wanted. Unconsciously, she gave him what he wanted, which was as little as possible. The fantasies were his, after all.
"The decision to have her dressed by Yves Saint-Laurent adds a bizarre dimension to the nonexistent plot; we seem to be living within the pages of a glossy magazine, with product placement everywhere. Everywhere Severine goes, she is conspicuous by her catwalk presence, from her shiny patent leather pumps to the helmet that holds in her mane of Barbie-doll hair.
"The sex scenes in the brothel consist of her stripping to the full armour of suspender-belt, knickers, stockings and padded brassiere, and allowing ugly men to kiss her. In one extraordinarily unsexy sequence, she is required to process through the rooms of a ducal chateau dressed in nothing but a cloak of black georgette and a crown of white roses. She trots ahead of the camera like a lamb to the slaughter. She should have used a body double; it is typical of her passive obedience that she didn't.
"Lauren Bacall would never have done that for anyone, would never have stripped and had them shoot her bare arse from the back as she trotted through take after take. The Hawksian woman would have decked any man who asked her." -- from a thoughtful, somewhat revisionist Guardian piece by Germaine Greer, the subject being the decline of the feisty broad.
Posted by Jeffrey Wells on December 31, 2006 at 2:16 PM
comment #1
Hallick
says ...
"from a thoughtful, somewhat revisionist Guardian piece by Germaine Greer, the subject being the decline of the feisty broad."
They don't ALL have to be, and never will all be, "feisty broads". Vive la difference.
Posted by Hallick
at December 31, 2006 2:51 PM
comment #2
T. S. Idiot
says ...
I love Bunuel, especially Exterminating Angel and the films of the 70s, but have always found, on three or four viewings, Belle to be overrated. Interesting but dramatically tepid. I agree with Gerry about feisty broads. They're the best.
Posted by T. S. Idiot
at December 31, 2006 3:42 PM
comment #3
Mgmax, le Corbeau
says ...
I admire Belle de Jour for Bunuel's brilliant hat trick at finding a way to make a chicly commercial Bunuel film that is still, unmistakably, a Bunuel film.
And I've always thought the key to Deneuve's performance is that Bunuel loved Buster Keaton so much.
Most of Greer's insights strike me as the butt-obvious sort-- the glossily banal, advertising-like visuals stand in contrast to the perverse content? By george I think you're on to something!
Posted by Mgmax, le Corbeau
at December 31, 2006 5:26 PM
comment #4
bellepoitrine
says ...
Don't kid yourself. Bacall would have done it if Bunuel had paid her enough.
Posted by bellepoitrine
at December 31, 2006 7:39 PM
comment #5
jeffmcm
says ...
Stop the presses! Greer is tolling the death knell of the 'feisty broad' and it only took her forty years to figure it out!
Posted by jeffmcm
at December 31, 2006 8:24 PM
comment #6
Ju-osh
says ...
Greer only touches upon it briefly here, but for a really detailed look at how Bacall was 'created' by Hawks, check out David Thomson's BFI Film Classics book on The Big Sleep. You'll never look at homegirl the same way again (and the rest of the book is fun, too!).
Posted by Ju-osh
at January 1, 2007 8:23 PM
comment #7
MBT
says ...
New arrival tiffany jewelry is on online shopping. Choose the latest style of 2010 tiffany silver jewelry here. At the same time, to buy 2010 fashionable christian louboutin make you become fashion frontier; ed hardy clothing on line store Uniquecool.uk.com provide Ed hardy clothing, free worldwide shipping and 50-75% discount Ed hardy is your great choice for cheap Ed hardy ; cartier jewelry is one of most famous luxury jewelry in the world. shinyawl.com offer cartier jewelry 50-70% discount, free shipping can help get cartier jewellery more easy; Purchase links of london jewellery on our site is a good choice for your luxury links London life , cheap links of London like links of London chrams and Links of London bracelets is waiting for you ; Looking for nfl jerseys online? Put the order on our site for NFL team jerseys if you are a real NFL fans. Have a nice day!
Posted by MBT
at June 30, 2010 9:02 PM
comment #8
wulitou84
says ...
cheap Ralph Lauren you should question its truth, for bags has never had the brown shammy epithelial tissue, even in a restoring ancient ways. Test notebook PC, with the zip zip fastener, buckles and also other hardware, you can get the handbag, christian louboutin shoes must they have top quality LV. Zipper should be brass hardware and large tactility, and think. Whenever any crease ralph lauren polo shirts which includes, this is false.
In case you see any cheap christian louboutin slanting as well as from, this will become a glimmer of untrue. Louis vuitton % great their enthusiasm for output, the hand of the 1850 s purse as well as handbag. They carefully designed louis vuitton outlet should be put in the bag and LV is put in the handbag and harmonious position.
Posted by wulitou84
at October 18, 2011 8:06 AM