Fearless Manhattan journo Lewis Beale has passed along his '06 superlatives -- here are a few: (a) The Best: Inside Man, United 93, Little Miss Sunshine, Half Nelson, Pan's Labyrinth, The Proposition, Babel, The Departed, Casino Royale, Children of Men; (b) The Worst: The Notorious Betty Page, London, Freedomland, Talladega Nights, A Guide to Recognizing Your Saints, Fast Food Nation; (c) Underrated: Brick, Find Me Guilty, Hollywoodland, Clerks II, Miami Vice, The Fountain, Apocalypto, Come Early Morning; (d) Overrated: Volver, Borat, Dreamgirls; (e) Full Disclosure: Beale has not seen Letters From Iwo Jima; (f) Guilty Pleasures: Glory Road, Slither, Invincible, Something New.
On top of (g) Best Doper Movie: The Fountain; (h) Best Pre-Columbian Chase Film: Apocalypto; (i) Best Film I Saw In 2006 Which Won't Be Released Until Later This Year: The Lives of Others, a brilliant German movie about East Germany's Stasi security system, in which a rigid spy becomes humanized after he is assigned to get information on a noted playwright and his actress lover; (j) Patti Labelle "I Can Sing Really Loud and Shatter Glass" Award: Jennifer Holiday; (k) Great-Looking Grunge: The Proposition.
Beale's Favorite Scenes: (1) The highway chase in Children of Men; (2) The construction site chase in Casino Royale; (3) The awesomely trippy final 15 minutes of The Fountain; (4) Martin Sheen thrown off the roof in The Departed; (5) Abigail Breslin dancing to "Super Freak" in Little Miss Sunshine; (6) The Motown dance number in Clerks II; (7) A female cop telling a white supremacist what a bullet from a high-powered rifle will do to his head in Miami Vice; (8) Any time Meryl Streep gets bitchy in The Devil Wears Prada; (9) Newark air traffic controllers watching as one of the lethal planes passes [a mile or so] in front of them, heading for the Twin Towers, in United 93; and (10) Ashley Judd not knowing how to deal with a lover who just wants to caress her in Come Early Morning.
Posted by Jeffrey Wells on January 6, 2007 at 9:08 AM
comment #1
jjgittes
says ...
"Talladega Nights" was a riot - I think he needs to lighten up.
"Borat" isn't overrated either - you can't rate it highly enough. It's a work of Art - not merely hilarious and entertaining but a movie that's actually about how we live right now.
People toss words like "daring" and "original" around all the time, and when a movie (finally) comes along that actually is - they call it "overrated"......yawn.
Posted by jjgittes
at January 6, 2007 9:49 AM
comment #2
austin111
says ...
Talladega Nights and Borat are both overrated. Borat is funnier though.
Posted by austin111
at January 6, 2007 10:36 AM
comment #3
Circumvrent
says ...
Jennifer Holiday, or Hudson?
Pretty good list: good to see The Fountain getting recognition, and Clerks II getting some as well. He's way off-base with Talledega Nights, however.
Posted by Circumvrent
at January 6, 2007 12:36 PM
comment #4
jeffmcm
says ...
I don't think Talladega Nights is overrated, because unlike Borat, people aren't calling it one of the year's best movies, or saying silly things about 'how we live right now' about it. Plus Borat does not hold up to multiple viewings.
Posted by jeffmcm
at January 6, 2007 3:31 PM