During my London-fog period of a couple of days ago, Salt Lake City Weekly film critic Scott Renshaw ran a noteworthy piece on Bilge Ebiri's Screengrab, voicing a view that "serious-minded filmmakers need to begin tackling issues of spirituality, in order not to leave it to the hacks."
HE response: The finest all-time films have always been about spiritual connections between wayward mortals and something eternal or transcendent (like Anthony Quinn's moment on the beach at the very end of La Strada), but serious filmmakers need to stay away, far away, from films about faith or religion. Leave faith films to the hacks (i.e., the purveyors of the mostly conservative, faith-based market), which is where they belong.
"The reason that Fox Faith and its slate of noxious innocuousness can exist is that there's a vacuum to be filled," wries Renshaw, "in case The Passion of the Christ and the success of [the gross and ghastly] Tyler Perry had not made that excruciatingly clear. Mainstream cinema generally seems scared to death of dealing with religion or faith in any way, for fear of giving offense." Quite so! And for good reason.
"How many fingers does it take," Renshaw asks, "to count the number of fiction films you've seen in the last 15 years, even in art houses, where a character's religious beliefs played a significant role in the events?"
And how many times has it been repeated that there's a huge whopping difference between people who feel the only true path to communion with all things Christian and eternal is through "faith" (a word pretty much owned by American heartland types) and through established religions with tax-deductible status, and the free-thinking, stand-alone satori crowd -- i.e., the spiritual seekers, mystics and knowers who feel that anyone who uses the word "faith" in the first place is going "baaaah" and doesn't really get it in the first place?
Apart from being inclined to wear vaguely uncool hair styles and clothing from Target and J.C. Penney-type stores, people who are into "faith" are, I believe, good-hearted souls who, for the best of reasons, are basically into submission and, in a manner of speaking, a kind of spiritual cluelessness.
Faith people are basically saying the same thing in cultures around the globe, which is this: in order to derive a sense of spiritual comfort, I am committed to regularly proclaiming a belief in a wondrous and eternal realm that I can't see or touch but which I believe lies on the other side of the door. I am but a lamb but proudly so, knowing as I do that God wants me to maintain a certain devotional ignorance. It is not my task to truly know, much less commune with, cosmic wonders and truths.
But a true mystic and spiritualist, someone who feels a greater kinship with (take your pick or make your own list) the writings of Herman Hesse, Aldous Huxley and Alan Watts than, say, the stiff-necked, drop-your-money-in-the-collection- plate creeds of traditional Catholics or Baptists or right-wing evangelists -- that liberal-minded person regularly communes with and in fact knows -- has savored, tasted, swum in -- the spiritual nectar of that realm beyond the door. The interconnected cosmic totality of it all resides within, and both sides of the door are equal parts of the equation. And either you've been there and are living there right now, or you haven't and you're not.
Faith, in short, is for spiritual pikers -- believers in ritual and community and constancy who sense a certain cosmic order and altogetherness but haven't really formulated it, and in some cases would even prefer not to. There's nothing wrong in the least with being an adherent of this or that religion -- anything the least bit soul-nourishing or soul-sustaining is obviously good to clasp to one's breast -- but faith is for the flock and true mystical God-knowledge is for the shepherd.
The only way I'll accept a film about a spiritual matter or river of any sort -- a depiction, say, of the life of Yeshua of Nazareth, to name but one topic -- is if it's directed by an artist who would rather listen to late '90s Limp Bizkit or John Coltrane than go to church on Sunday. Pier Palo Pasolini's The Gospel According to St. Matthew is my kind of spirit movie. Or Martin Scorsese's The Last Temptation of Christ, which the hard-core faith types, fired by their charming righteous certainty, demonstrated against in 1988 outside of movie theatres.
That idiotic response to Scorsese's film opened my eyes to the essential blindness and bigotry of conservative Christianity, which, as we all know, is a very powerful social force in Salt Lake City. Which is why I (and hundreds of others, I'm fairly sure) quickly discounted Renshaw's piece when it first appeared on Screengrab. It's impossible not to suspect that he's picking up on that SLC vibe and trying to run with it in an erudite film critic-type way. If the piece had been written by, say, a Hassidic Jew from Manhattan's Lower East Side, I would have seemed a different matter.
Posted by Jeffrey Wells on March 14, 2007 at 6:33 AM
comment #1
EwanC
says ...
*Gulp* ... Let the fighting commence....
Posted by EwanC
at March 14, 2007 8:40 AM
comment #2
westegg
says ...
Absolutely terrific meditation on an important topic. Even Kubrick's 2001 can be included as a search for the transcendental. Kubrick himself had great respect for "the great unknown," without getting bogged down in the easy sentimentalities of faith or religion. It's also good to see a director such as Scorcese be attuned to these themes; let's hope with the success of THE DEPARTED he can afford to do a few more along these lines. This is where art and mystery can truly create something extraordinary.
Posted by westegg
at March 14, 2007 8:47 AM
comment #3
NYCBusybody
says ...
Wells, I'd like to hear you say the exact same things about adherents to Islam - the negativity, the hatred, the derision you have.
I'm assuming that even as idiotic as you are, wearing Target clothing isn't as egregious an offense as holy-war inspired suicide bombing.
Which, of course, is really the point. The REAL tragedy of filmmaking today is the utter lack of artistic balls. ANYONE can attack "Heartland" types, and do, for their supposed sheep-like conformity to organized religion. William Donohue might issue a press statement or two, and rubes like me with improper thread count t-shirts will rabble about it in posts like these.
Mildly criticize Islam? End up like Theo Van Gogh.
Cowards like Wells NEVER mention Islam, which is the PRIMARY religion in the world today that invokes the name of God in horrible, terrible acts of oppression and violence.
Do they do this out of fear? Of course, although American journalists don't worry about it as much, because they're relatively safe here (thanks to Bush-Cheney, no thanks to cowards like Clinton, who was held in check by venally evil liberals, whose deaths cannot be swift enough, praise Allah). I think it's done purely out of sheeplike-comfort, though, which is, ironically, the exact thing they are always on the attack about.
Have some balls, Wells. Be a maverick.
Posted by NYCBusybody
at March 14, 2007 9:02 AM
comment #4
MAGGA
says ...
moving off topic here, but Limp Bizkit? You must be joking. Apart from that, great read. And NYC, he was talking about all religions which of cours includes Islam. So there
Posted by MAGGA
at March 14, 2007 9:11 AM
comment #5
NYCBusybody
says ...
On second thought, don't. You'll be killed by a Muslim within the week, guaranteed, and even I don't wish for your death.
And that's my last post on this thread, I don't want to contribute any more than I already have to cheap hit-count grabs.
God almighty, how this site has fallen in recent years.
Posted by NYCBusybody
at March 14, 2007 9:12 AM
comment #6
NYCBusybody
says ...
He's talking about all religions? I saw Christians mentioned...I saw American heartland types mentioned...
If he was making a pan-religion statement, he wouldn't have specified anyone. He's a coward and he knows it. And a particularly idiotic one, which is of course why his life has amounted to getting snubbed by Scott Caan and blogging about the Oscars from a hotel.
Posted by NYCBusybody
at March 14, 2007 9:14 AM
comment #7
christian
says ...
thanks to bush cheney, who were in charge on 9/11?
and you wish the death of liberals praise allah?
like i said, you neo-cons think just like the terrorists. all you left out was the word "faggot."
of course, democrots like cleland and kerry fought in a war unlike your alcholic president and his ceo vp who "had other priorities."
"Apart from being inclined to wear vaguely uncool hair styles and clothing from Target and J.C. Penney-type stores, people who are into "faith" are, I believe, good-hearted souls who, for the best of reasons, are basically into submission and, in a manner of speaking, a kind of spiritual cluelessness."
talk about clueless. your faith is that people who have it are morons? you have faith when you get into an airplane it will fly or that you're not going to die tomorrow -- otherwise you'd be out finding value and meaning in life. and realizing you simply don't know either waym but that doesn't discount the deep powerful feelings of connection that faith inspires.
why would a screenwriter spend a year writing without being paid? or an actor take demeaning roles for years? or anybody creating any art? because you believe.
yeah, i wish bergman had stayed away from issues of faith so we wouldn't have THE SEVENTH SEAL. or woody allen films. or 2001. or even PULP FICTION.
Posted by christian
at March 14, 2007 9:14 AM
comment #8
NYCBusybody
says ...
Bush-Cheney blew it in the lead-up to 9/11, but they've done a lot more since then to fix the problem than Clinton ever would or could have.
But leave it to the libs on this board to already stand up for degenerate Muslim scum.
I happen to like faggots, so I don't use that word.
Posted by NYCBusybody
at March 14, 2007 9:17 AM
comment #9
Ortega
says ...
To NYCBusybody:
Didn't you write in your second posting that it was going to be your last one? You were just about to make my day there for a moment. And yet I see you writing again almost immediately after. Way to dash my hopes man, that's cruel.
Posted by Ortega
at March 14, 2007 9:23 AM
comment #10
Josh Massey
says ...
I wear clothing from Target and my favorite film of 2006 was Children of Men. Where, praytell O God of Hipness Wells, do I fall?
Posted by Josh Massey
at March 14, 2007 9:26 AM
comment #11
NYCBusybody
says ...
I know, Ortega, I even let myself down.
Must...resist..adding...to...hitcount...
Posted by NYCBusybody
at March 14, 2007 9:29 AM
comment #12
Mr. Muckle
says ...
Very nice and moderate consideration, JW, to which NYC added his predictably idiotic dribbles. Although there are obviously a number of murderous nutjobs justifying themselves with religious quotations in Islam, it is fairly certain that NYC does not have the knowledge or experience to understand their causes and correctives, preferring the tactic of distracting us from cleaning up our own houses by suggesting "that other bastard's house is dirtier than mine."
In my opinion, Christianity went off the rails fairly soon after its inception (with its claims of exclusivity and its own obscenely violent ways of trying to enforce conformity), and an original impulse in Islam was a corrective to some of these.
Nowadays it's beyond retarded merely to be able to point out the rampant corruption in some other guy's religion, while giving lifetime passes to our homegrown mullahs like Pat Robertson, Jerry Falwell, and even that famous converter of the Bush, Billy Graham.
In a country leading the world in wealth and weapons, together with their misuse in gathering more of the same to the grave detriment of others, NYC does not even begin to account for the damage done by those assholes and their sycophants, so gee whiz, it's a mystery to him why so many of them dang foreigners despise him.
Posted by Mr. Muckle
at March 14, 2007 9:32 AM
comment #13
NYCBusybody
says ...
I account for Falwell and Robertson. I hate them. I'm an atheist.
How long has it been since an abortion-clinic was bombed? How many homosexuals are hung from trees in America?
I point out the idiocy in all religion. You don't, because you're a despicable coward who doesn't care about the lifes of people who suffer under the oppression of Islam, because you see all non-Europeans as one big mass of victims for you to protect and defend. They're just Third-world pawns to you, no less than to any Bush or Cheney, but you're too mindless to understand that. So I'll have to point it out to you.
Posted by NYCBusybody
at March 14, 2007 9:37 AM
comment #14
NYCBusybody
says ...
And if foreigners despise me for that, bring it on. I'm proud to be hated by people I hate.
Posted by NYCBusybody
at March 14, 2007 9:38 AM
comment #15
NYCBusybody
says ...
And yes, if pushed to it, I do think there is a semblance of humanity to even the most zealotous (word?) Christians that I don't see in Islamic counterparts.
But as long as liberals care more about Falwell than Bin Laden, people will suffer in Afghanistan, and Iran, and Iraq, and Palestine, under the hand of oppressive religion.
But you sure feel good for sticking it to Target, don'tcha? Idiots.
Posted by NYCBusybody
at March 14, 2007 9:40 AM
comment #16
Craig Kennedy
says ...
I don't know. Once again I find myself agreeing with Wells in the big picture but being put off by his sneering tone of superiority.
I'm no fan of your average religious screwball whatever flag he or she is waving, but I take no issue with them seeking to get a grip on a nervous, angry and irrational world by acting like they have all the answers as long as they keep the bombs to themselves (whether the target is a skyscraper in Manhattan or an abortion clinic in Memphis makes no difference to me).
When it comes to movies though, I prefer the ones that ask spiritual questions rather than pretend to provide all the answers. Save the preaching for Sunday church. Instead, show me characters that are grappling with the notion of their existence in the same ways I am.
To answer Renshaw's question about how many I've seen "in the last 15 years where a character's religious beliefs played a significant role": I think he's defining religious beliefs too narrowly. They may not always be overtly couched in the language of one specific religion or another, but the movies I see are filled with spiritual struggles and moral questions. That's my religion.
Posted by Craig Kennedy
at March 14, 2007 9:46 AM
comment #17
Mr. Muckle
says ...
NYC, I think that basically you're too transparently hot under the collar and knee-jerk reactionary to warrant trying to have a sane and civil discussion with you. Go on hating, then. The point is that's not the solution, that's the problem.
Posted by Mr. Muckle
at March 14, 2007 10:03 AM
comment #18
Rich S.
says ...
I respect Jeffrey's position on the matter, but I think he defeats his own argument. How can one equate spirituality with status obsession? What does the fact that one shops at J.C. Penney's or Target have the least bit to do with one's spiritual health?
Jeffrey is a deeply conflicted individual. We've seen what he drives. We know that he risks his life and property each day to make his tea in a rusted misshapen pot. He's posted pictures on this site of the extraordinarily expensive skin care products he uses. He has had to ask for donations to keep his site running, and yet he routinely travels to destinations the average person can only dream of.
In many ways, he presents himself as austere, but then he degrades clothing for having insufficient thread count. His limited though contradictory views seriously damage his credibility.
Spirituality is where you find it. I was moved by the end of Titanic, which had nothing to do with religion. I was also fascinated by Charlton Heston's conversation with Rex Harrison concerning the portrayal of God in The Agony and the Ecstasy, which is otherwise about as ham fisted as you can get on the subject. I admired The Passion of the Christ, The Last Temptation of Christ and Monty Python's Life of Brian, all of which I thought had fascinating things to say about religion and spirituality.
I've always liked Chris Rock's speech in Dogma, where he observes that mankind took faith, which is a very good thing, and then loused it up by building up belief systems around it. In many cases, I find that is true about religion. But I wouldn't go so far as to say that all, or even the majority of, adherents to any religion fit any type of particular stereotype. To do so fits the very definition of narrow minded.
Posted by Rich S.
at March 14, 2007 10:07 AM
comment #19
cobhome
says ...
Shopping at Bloomingdale's is not a sure sign of intellectual or spiritual superiority - and it is patently absurd to suggest so - Jeff - you run a great site and 90% of the time I love what you have to say - but your snobbery is really a drag - and thoroughly inconsistent with anykind of spirituality. Your remarks reflect so many levels of ignorance it is hard to even begin to address them but there is one thing I would say - the bloodbaths occurring in places like Iraq - Darfur - the Congo etc etc - did not start out as bloodbaths - they started out with people seperating themselves into the us's and thems - the folks who shop at Target versus the folks who shop at Bloomies ( or whatever store suits you) - ridiculing - stereotyping - reducing to absurd levels of simplicty the beliefs of others - is divisive - and starts us down the slippery slope towards violent confrontation. Please consider that next time you want to make a statement.
Posted by cobhome
at March 14, 2007 10:08 AM
comment #20
Mr. Muckle
says ...
Jeff's essential point (as I perceive it) is to make a distinction between mere believers and people with experience. Mere believers are sometimes not even aware there is such a thing as "experience" in spiritual/religious affairs, which trumps a system of belief, and they often even actively deny there could be such a thing. After all, the authority of experience (and the knowledge derived from it) trumps the authority of bureaucracy on which the shell of so-called religion depends.
Sure, he could possibly have put it more diplomatically in certain ways, but that would not stir up the process. Mostly, it appears that people react to the superficial and don't care about theh essence. So Target, Penney's, blah, blah. Who cares? I get my clothes the cheapest way possible and I'm past caring about being cool.
But to have an idea of the difference between a mere believer and, say, a "mystic knower" usually implies a level of evolvement beyond the usual, which is noteworthy.
Posted by Mr. Muckle
at March 14, 2007 10:22 AM
comment #21
truefaith
says ...
"Bush-Cheney blew it in the lead-up to 9/11, but they've done a lot more since then to fix the problem than Clinton ever would or could have."
Yeah, right, NYCGuy--Bush and Cheney did A LOT MORE since 9-11. They only made the terrorists, insurgents of Iraq, and al-Qaeda stronger. Now I feel a lot safer knowing that the terrorists are stronger and better equipped to bomb a baseball field in Phillie. Thanks Bush and Cheney for that.
Also, Bush and Cheney helped the Shiites in the Middle East to become stronger. Now there is an even greater chance that there will be an all out war in the Middle East between the once-dominated Sunnis and oil-hungry Shiites. Again, thanks Bush and Cheney for that. Isn't the world supposed to end in the Middle East? Well, Bush and Cheney are wasting no time to make that happen.
NYCGuy likes Bush and Cheney probably because he is making a ton of money from his oil stock inventments. As far as I am concerned, Bush is the worst president in modern times.
Posted by truefaith
at March 14, 2007 10:25 AM
comment #22
ArchiveGuy
says ...
"Jeff's essential point (as I perceive it) is to make a distinction between mere believers and people with experience. Mere believers are sometimes not even aware there is such a thing as "experience" in spiritual/religious affairs, which trumps a system of belief, and they often even actively deny there could be such a thing. After all, the authority of experience (and the knowledge derived from it) trumps the authority of bureaucracy on which the shell of so-called religion depends."
The problem, though, is that JW posits the two as mutually exclusive--if you are a person of "faith", then by virtue of that faith, you render all the transcendent experiences out there in the world as inaccessible. Only by being divorced from the stringent systems that define his perception of "faith" can one truly experience a spiritual moment.
Which is, of course, horseshit.
Many people have "faith" because it was hoisted on them from birth and they've led reclusive, insular lives in one-track-mind communities. But just as many (if not more) have had transcendent, genuinely spiritual experiences and choose to interpret or process them in a way that's obviously to JW's disapproval. Unless we achieve awakening just like he does, it's not "real".
Which, again, is utter horseshit.
Posted by ArchiveGuy
at March 14, 2007 11:00 AM
comment #23
ratskiwatski
says ...
I was literally five minutes away from firing up "Passion of Joan of Arc" when I checked in on this, but, instead - Let The Cartoons... Begin!
I'm your garden variety messed-up-ex-Catholic, now live-and-let-live-agnostic-heathen-fuck, and Renshaw's article kind of amused me. Take away the "Faith" from "Fox Faith" in that sentence and a more germane point emerges. Mainstream American filmmaking is and always has been averse to giving off a sniff of offense on any topic, period. It takes so much guile and infighting to get anything of any heft made, anything that isn't completely vapid... why should religion - more appropriately, spirituality - be exempt from the Great Lathe That Smooths All Edges? Not even Walden Media has the stones to make the Christian subtext (forget that - *text*) explicit in a C.S. Lewis adaptation, because they're not imbued with either deep spiritual or artistic sense - it's about the "family friendly" market sector... "Narnia" Happy Meals... in God We Trust. And why not? The low-hanging fruit is so much easier to pick.
What a surprise - something like Michael Tolkin's "The Rapture" (my opinion, the greatest American film I've ever seen about these matters) played to three customers and a projectionist while "Hostel" - oh, sorry, I meant "Passion of the Christ" - spoke to so many. And "Wild Hogs" outgrossed "Zodiac" - knock me over with a fucking feather. And, in further developments, Martin Scorsese is still hypovolemic from the quarts of blood he had to give up to film "Last Temptation," and "Rambo IV" is slated for an early 2008 release... sometime Easterish.
Posted by ratskiwatski
at March 14, 2007 11:02 AM
comment #24
cobhome
says ...
Yeah - Bush is doing a gruesome, appalling job - but ya know - his predecessors weren't knights in shining armor and frankly - our democratic controlled congress is now happily reneging on the commitments Bush made to the whole "Make poverty history" effort - I have this suspicion that the issue isn't our leadership - it is us - the American people - would the politics of the Middle East have an impact on the world if Americans weren't guzzling gas - to totally blame Bush for that is silly.
I was in London when the terrorist attacks on the underground occurred - lots of chat re: "innocents" being hurt - a friend - who is Islamic - made an observation that continues to stay with me - that if we really have democratic societies in the West - than there can be no such thing as an innocent - for all actions of our governments are sanctioned by all of us - and we all have the power to change the course of our govenments actions. The comment has made me less inclined to rail against Bush and more inclined to look at what my own responsibility is for shaping the country I live in.
I am disinclined to think that new age gurus are mystics in the real meaning of that word - and at any rate - the great tradition of mysticism derives from the great religions - the sufi's of Islam- the monastic communties of Catholicism ( Merton anyone?) and certainly the traditions of Jewish mysticism ( the Kabbalists) etc etc. and the presence of doubt - uncertainty - informs all of the great organized religions. Much of the intellectual, scholastic achievements of western civilization were made by people of profound religious faith - the philospohical basis for rationalism ( ya know - the enlightenment?) were articulated by a couple of scottish presbyterians - one of whom was a bishop -
I do think Scorses's fascination with turning the novel "The Silence" into a film is a fine example of what Scott Renshaw is asking for - a complex deeply spiritual story of Jesuit missionaries - that explores deep issues of human experience - the existence of suffering - the search for meaning - the matter of faith - and those adherents to organized religions who do delve deeper into the mystery of faith - films such as this certainly should be made -
Posted by cobhome
at March 14, 2007 11:13 AM
comment #25
filmradar.com
says ...
Did it ever dawn on you that not all Christians fit into a stereotype? I am a Christian and get this....I'm also a liberal. I support gay marriage and pro-choice. I am a registered Democrat. I live in Los Angeles (not the midwest.) There are MANY other people like me out there.
Posted by filmradar.com
at March 14, 2007 11:24 AM
comment #26
Joe Leydon
says ...
So Jeff: What do you make of the deeply religious -- and, yes, deeply Christian -- folks who were/are at the forefront of the abolitionist, civil rights and anti-war movements because such activity was/is their way of practising what they preach?
BTW: I am writing this while seated in a way-cool Austin coffee shop, after seeing a documentary about Abu Ghraib, while wearing a shirt I bought at Target, jeans I bought at Penney's, and boots I bought at Wal-Mart.
Posted by Joe Leydon
at March 14, 2007 11:41 AM
comment #27
Craig Kennedy
says ...
Before buy into Jeff's assertion of his own spiritual superiority, let's just remember this is the same guy who greeted news of Scorsese possibly making The Silence with a complete dismissal of the outstanding Kundun and an open wish that he'd stick to gangster pictures. Remember that the next time you're slumming at Target or JC Penny.
Posted by Craig Kennedy
at March 14, 2007 11:45 AM
comment #28
Armin Tamzarian
says ...
filmradar.com, you are not alone. There are many more of us than Wells would ever dream possible. His stereotypical, sanctimonious, elitist, ignorant rants instill a sense of rage in me that soon gives way to sadness. As time goes on, he appears more and more to be a sad, lonely man in a fruitless pursuit to fill a void deep within himself, living in the confines of deep-seated denial.
Posted by Armin Tamzarian
at March 14, 2007 11:57 AM
comment #29
jeffmcm
says ...
This is the stupidest thing out of many stupid things that Wells has ever posted.
Jeffrey Wells: you are one of the worst people alive. Stop calling yourself hip, a journalist, an important tastemaker. You are an arrogant, elitist, snobbish, liberal kook.
Posted by jeffmcm
at March 14, 2007 12:00 PM
comment #30
christian
says ...
joe, which way-cool austin coffee shop are you in? i miss 'em all.
i'm assuming spider house or the flight path or little city...
Posted by christian
at March 14, 2007 12:18 PM
comment #31
rocco
says ...
Posts like this cause me to seriously question, why do I continue to frequent a website where I know the proprietor despises me, yet gladly accepts the revenue I indirectly drive his way?...
...despite being a very open-minded, rational person, very highly educated with several degrees (incl. Physics), and someone who lives a very "blue-state" lifestyle in every way (metropolitan setting with a healthy breadth of movies, food, tastes, an openness and eagerness to experience new things, etc, etc) I am also a person of FAITH. Despite all of my education and exposure to all kinds of worldly experiences--not to mention deeply painful loss that would presumably shatter one's faith--I CHOOSE to believe that there is knowledge beyond the grasp of man...I choose to believe in a place called hope...sorry, couldn't help myself...I choose to believe that there is something, call it God if you like, that gives us the ability and burden of contemplating our lives and our existence. I embrace science and man's quest to understand our origins and feel strongly that science and the concept of spirituality are complementary, and I do not ask that anyone share my beliefs...
...if that makes me irrational, stupid, sheepish, or any other adjective secular folks like to throw around, then so be it...but *I* know that my faith comes from a place of enlightenment after deep contemplation and reflection, and if myopic, intolerant jitbags like Jeff are dismissive, so be it...it makes the irony of their own faith in man-made enlightenment all the more amusing.
Posted by rocco
at March 14, 2007 12:19 PM
comment #32
Joshua Mooney
says ...
Nice to find another "Rapture" fan. Agree with the rest of your take, too.
"What a surprise - something like Michael Tolkin's "The Rapture" (my opinion, the greatest American film I've ever seen about these matters) played to three customers and a projectionist while "Hostel" - oh, sorry, I meant "Passion of the Christ" - spoke to so many. And "Wild Hogs" outgrossed "Zodiac" - knock me over with a fucking feather. And, in further developments, Martin Scorsese is still hypovolemic from the quarts of blood he had to give up to film "Last Temptation," and "Rambo IV" is slated for an early 2008 release... sometime Easterish.
Posted by: ratskiwatski at March 14, 2007 11:02 AM"
Posted by Joshua Mooney
at March 14, 2007 12:21 PM
comment #33
f.bush
says ...
NYC Busybody:
I don't care what "Liberals" think about Fallwell or Bin Laden. I've been waiting for almost six years for the people in charge of this Country to capture or kill the bastard. All we've gotten in those six years is the wrong war perpetuated by lies, three thousand of our dedicated service men and women killed for no reason, God knows how many dead Iraqi men, women, and children, complete incompetence in every phase of the Occupation of Iraq, complete incompetence in response to Katrina, a world far more dangerous for Americans than before Bush started this bogus war. Isn't Walter Reade the last straw even for people like you?
Posted by f.bush
at March 14, 2007 12:21 PM
comment #34
Mr. Muckle
says ...
ArchiveGuy: "The problem, though, is that JW posits the two as mutually exclusive--if you are a person of "faith", then by virtue of that faith, you render all the transcendent experiences out there in the world as inaccessible. Only by being divorced from the stringent systems that define his perception of "faith" can one truly experience a spiritual moment. Which is, of course, horseshit."
I don't read that in what he said. Of course, perhaps it's not necessary to say that people of faith are "spiritual pikers." We could say that the various systems of religious belief (here called "faith") are more like elementary schools. However, it is not commonly said that we have to do our work and graduate from school. If we don't, then we ARE pikers. There's a difference between, say, reading about food in Gourmet Magazine, and cooking eating a fine meal. One is not exclusive to the other; they're different things.
ArchiveGuy: "Many people have "faith" because it was hoisted on them from birth and they've led reclusive, insular lives in one-track-mind communities. But just as many (if not more) have had transcendent, genuinely spiritual experiences and choose to interpret or process them in a way that's obviously to JW's disapproval. Unless we achieve awakening just like he does, it's not "real".
Which, again, is utter horseshit."
My mother was pretty much a churchy person. At some point in her life when I was young, she describes having had something of a "mystical" experience that, on its own merits, sounded fine. But soon she used it to justify so much literalistic, church-based interpretation that it was pretty much dead as far as I was concerned. That represented a devolution to me. You can't squeeze the atmosphere into a bottle. If you could, Bush would be charging you $60 a barrel for it.
cobhome: "I am disinclined to think that new age gurus are mystics in the real meaning of that word - and at any rate - the great tradition of mysticism derives from the great religions - the sufi's of Islam- the monastic communties of Catholicism ( Merton anyone?) and certainly the traditions of Jewish mysticism ( the Kabbalists) etc etc. and the presence of doubt - uncertainty - informs all of the great organized religions."
That's quite a worthwhile disinclination, imo. They are not real mystics, just childish pretenders.
While the genuine mystics and realizers may have grown up in a tradition, it's pretty much by definition that they have transcended those traditions, even if they continue to outwardly practice them. At some level, what does it matter then?
But they will not be party to exclusivist sentiments and superiority complexes about it, having seen something essential and true that informs all genuine religious inspirations.
Posted by Mr. Muckle
at March 14, 2007 12:25 PM
comment #35
ratskiwatski
says ...
Tamzarian - I'm just glad you didn't end your psych evaluation with a spirited, yet sadly knowing, "Up Yours, Children!"
Because that wouldn't be, well, Christian...
Posted by ratskiwatski
at March 14, 2007 12:29 PM
comment #36
Ju-osh
says ...
Limp Bizkit was NEVER considered cool or interesting or daring by anyone with even a minimum of musical taste, Jeff. I'm guessing you think they're a 'hip' name to drop because David Fincher once worked with Limp Bizkit's lead singer on an aborted version of the film The Lords Of Dogtown. Well, you're wrong.
Posted by Ju-osh
at March 14, 2007 1:20 PM
comment #37
nola
says ...
Jeff should read the article in the NYTs about "the three amigos". I think it is fascinating how their Catholic upbringing has influenced their work.
I am sick of people esp. in this town being so self-righteous about not believing in anything except making money. Some of the most incredible art in the world would not be here if it where not for faith, some of our laws would not exist where it not for Judeo-christian beliefs. Enough already with the slamming of people who believe in something. We are not all fanatics. I consider myself a Christian, love Prada and Gucci and have never stepped into a Walmart (they didn't have them where I used to live...which was Manhattan, the bluest of the blue) . Jeff is tripping.
Posted by nola
at March 14, 2007 1:23 PM
comment #38
rocco
says ...
Wow, missed the Limp Bizkit reference the first time I read it...a guy who talks about enlightenment and having visited the other side of the door who would waste one precious second on this earth listening to Limp FUCKING Bizkit!!?? Is Jeff parodying himself?? Holy fucking shit...
...I'm sorry I spent as much time as I did responding the first time...a guy whose singular fixation is in being hip is not someone who's looking for an intellectual conversation about reconciling faith and spirituality with free-mindedness and rational thought. What a fucking maroon, trapped on his own little desert island where approval, not water, is his only concern.
Seriously, this is the stupidest fucking thing you have ever posted...so stupid it avoids offense.
Posted by rocco
at March 14, 2007 1:53 PM
comment #39
Hallick
says ...
"I consider myself a Christian, love Prada and Gucci and have never stepped into a Walmart (they didn't have them where I used to live...which was Manhattan, the bluest of the blue) . Jeff is tripping." - nola
Jeff IS tripping. His cartoonish impressions of the religious is brain-blind. And it would make the evangelicals and mormons I know laugh their asses off at him. I live in a rather heartland-type small town, and as hard as it is for Mr. Wells to believe, these guys can run circles around most anybody else when it comes to clothes, hair, technology, music, etc.
I don't share their beliefs, but I do envy their sense of community and optimism. And their mix of modernity and ancient dogma would be a fascinating subject for films or television shows. There just has to be some serious tension in the middle of it all.
Posted by Hallick
at March 14, 2007 7:37 PM
comment #40
cobhome
says ...
seems like a lot of people stop growing in their understanding of religious faith at about ten - and then have adult experiences which challenge their ten year old child understanding of religion - and come to the conclusion that religion stinks - right Jeff?
read that something like 85% of all Americans believe in a personal God - reverse is true in Europe -15% believe in a personal God - does this explain Fellini?
Posted by cobhome
at March 14, 2007 7:54 PM
comment #41
TheJeff
says ...
Wow. Jeff Welles is a deeply insecure man. His silly self-portrait of a hip, urban, well-connected intellectual used to strike me as the comical posturing of a confused middle-ager trying to stave off a mid-life crisis. Recently though, his finger-wagging swipes at everyone from inner-city "blings" to red-state Christians has bordered on pathetic.
Posted by TheJeff
at March 14, 2007 9:23 PM
comment #42
TL
says ...
Jeff, I've been reading you since the Reel.com days, and, all due respect, you're never more out of your depth than when you try to write about religion.
"the free-thinking, stand-alone satori crowd -- i.e., the spiritual seekers, mystics and knowers.... true mystical God-knowledge is for the shepherd. ..."
We all know you're just talking out of your ass here, so let's let that slide. What's truly remarkable is the way you acknowledge that your only frame of reference is "American heartland types," and then generalize your lack of experience to a concept as large as "faith" itself.
Why don't you just admit that you have no frame of reference on religious belief outside what's portrayed in the media by a small minority of loudmouthed knuckleheads instead of becoming the same type of knucklehead on the opposite end of the specturm?
Posted by TL
at March 15, 2007 7:01 AM
comment #43
gruver1
says ...
Wells to TL and all the others: Suck on it, deal with it -- the rabid-doofus Christian right of the U.S. of A. is not only real but deeply & profoundly loathsome, and no amount of bash-postings on this site is going to change that fact. That said, it's very pleasant to hear/be reminded of the fact that there are tens of thousands of moderate-minded, conscientious, decent-hearted Christians out there who hang out at cafes and read Rilke and Kant and wear high-thread-count T-shirts.
Posted by gruver1
at March 15, 2007 8:42 AM
comment #44
rocco
says ...
"That said, it's very pleasant to hear/be reminded of the fact that there are tens of thousands of moderate-minded, conscientious, decent-hearted Christians out there who hang out at cafes and read Rilke and Kant and wear high-thread-count T-shirts."
I'll read that remark as sincere, but only because Jesus would want me to...
...I wish I could end with that, but facetiousness doesn't translate well in print...
...no, I'll take that as sincere because I want to believe you really mean it. I have faith in you, Jeff...
Posted by rocco
at March 15, 2007 8:55 AM
comment #45
kimi98
says ...
Wells to TL and all the others: Suck on it, deal with it -- the rabid-doofus Christian right of the U.S. of A. is not only real but deeply & profoundly loathsome, and no amount of bash-postings on this site is going to change that fact. That said, it's very pleasant to hear/be reminded of the fact that there are tens of thousands of moderate-minded, conscientious, decent-hearted Christians out there who hang out at cafes and read Rilke and Kant and wear high-thread-count T-shirts
sexe
sexe
sexe
sexe
sexe
bondage
blowjob
blondeblaguesblagueblackblackbizarrebitebisexuelbisexual
beurettebedbikini
bebebeautybeachbdsmbbwbang_gangbang
acrobatbaise
babeavatarsavatarautoastuceassasiatiqueasian
ares
ad_awareanusantivirus_gratuitantivirusanimeanalamatriceamateuramateur
amateur
adultedivx_gratuitdivxdivxdirtydildodickdiaporamasdiaporama
deep_throat
cumshotcumculcreampiecouplecouplecouillecoquin
code_jeu
cockcochonclose_upcloneclitoriscinemacheatcharmechansons_gratuit
chanson_gratuit
chaleurcelebritecartooncartescartescartescartecartecarte
busty
bukkakebruneboybootyboobfilmsfilmsfilm_gratuitfilm_gratuitfilmfilm
ffm
fetishfetichismefetichefessefemmefemmefemmefemdomfellation
fat
famillefamilialefacialfacef_rallyeexoticexhibitionnisteetudianteethnic
erotisme
erotiqueserotiqueemuleemule_gratuitenfantenfantenculeremule_gratuitemoticonesemoticoneedonkeyecrans_de_veilleecran_de_veille
ebony
drunkdownloaddouble_penetrationiconehumourhumourhugehousewife
hothoroscopeshoroscopehomosexuelhistoire
hentaihardcorehardhandjobhairygrossegrosgratuitegratuitegratuitegratuitegratuitgratuitgratuitgratuitgrannygaygolfglory_holegirlgaygayfuckingfootjobfootball
footfonds_d_ecranfond_d_ecranflashingfisting
first_timefirefoxfingeringmilfmidgetmessenger_gratuitmessengermature
maturemasturbationmassagemardi_gras
mangamalemaidlogiciels_gratuitlogicielslogicielslogiciel_gratuitlogiciellogiciel
lingerielimewirelesbiennelesbianlatinaslatinalatexkazaa_gratuitkazaajeux
jeuxjeuxjeunejeujeu
jeujapaneseinterracial
indianimage_humourimageimageimageicqillusion
piedphoto
photophotophotopetitepenispartitionspartition
paroles_gratuitparole_gratuitpantieoutdoororientalorgyorgieorgasmeoralnudistenudistnudenunoirenero_gratuitneronaughtynaturenaturalnakedmusiques_gratuitesmusique_gratuitemusic_gratuitemuremsn_gratuitmsn
msn
mp_gratuitmoviemorpheusmommodelsmodel
mmfsexysexuellesex_gratuit
sexe_gratuitsexe_gratuitsexesexesexesexsexschoolgirlsalope
safarisadorousserimjobredheadrecettes
recettesrecette
recettereal_playerrasee
pussypuffyprogrammeprivatepregnantpps_pptpornstarporno_gratuit
porno_gratuitpornographiepornopornoporno
porn_gratuitpornpoitrineplumperpipe
pinkclip video xxx
hot xxx gay
sexe photo porno
photo and sexe and gratuit
sexe vieille mature
rencontre sexe senior
photo sexe black
photo sexe homme nu
sexe porno gratuit photo free
jeu online gratuit sexe
sexe extreme dilatation
hot sexe to brazil
film porno telecharger gratui
extrait porno video amateur
histoire de sexe gratuite
film xxx forum rapidshare
photo gratuit galerie tgp sexe
video demo porno gratos
video porno gratuit gros vagin
galerie photo sexe gratuite
video porno sex gratuit usa
femme mature porno
film xxx porno media player
xxx bd
sexe gay porno
epilation sexe homme
video de sexe extreme
sexe ultra bizarre
extrait video film porno
porno jeu video
video gratuite porno amateur
photo gratuite xxx hymens vierge
video sexe demo gratuite
plus grand site porno francais
photo femme sexe gratuit
video sexe lesbienne gouine gratuit
photo sexe amateur francais
mature nylon porno
humour sexe pps
liste meilleur site porno mature
beurette sexe avec voile
porno asiatique
black xxx mas
elisa actrice porno
sexe femme poilue photo gratuit france
sex cul porno
photo beurette sexe
femme xxx rencon
teacher sex xxx
xxx mangas hentai sakura
beurette sexe amateurt
clip xxx gratuitt
sexe mature hardt
jeu porno shockwavet
sky blog sexet
video preview free xxxt
free gay pornot
video porno voir gratui san telechargement
sexe rasee gratuitt
video de sexe a telechargert
porno gay transt
xxx hard xxx videot
video porno gratuit voirt
telecharger comic xxxt
sexe filmes livet
voir extrait gratuit video porno sans abonnementt
porno gratuit photot
sexe et vieille femmet
casting porno parist
mini video pornot
photo sexe amateur gratuit sans connexiont
sexe homme hommet
extrait film porno a telechargert
extrait video sexe blogt
disney porn xxxt
gratuit amateur sexet
hot young couple xxxt
liste acteur pornot
telechargement gratuit porno sexet
webcam live xxxt
extrait film porno femme soumiset
cam live free sexet
porno homme gay gratuitt
video sexe gratuite femme muret
photo porno amatricet
gratuit sexe videot
cul sexe pornot
clip video gratuit sexe debutantt
jouer au jeu pornot
porno free videot
pute arabe pornot
vente film pornot
larges extrait video porno gratuitt
film xxx gayt
sexe gratuit analt
photo sexet
sexe porno video gratuitt
petits extrait video de sexe gratuitt
photo porno gratuite femme blackt
i love sexe skyblogt
arabe pornot
agnes photo gratuite sexe vieillet
sexe porno cult
metz sexe amatricet
disney xxx sexet
histoire porno d adot
video amatrice cul xxxt
video porno gratuite a visionnert
sexe shop toulouset
photo gratuit xxxt
annuaire forum sexet
mami salope xxxt
sexe amateur hard gratuitt
sexe hard photo gratuitet
photo salope xxxt
photo galerie cul latine porno start
webcam sex adult pornot
cam frog sexe freet
comic xxxt
live show audio sexet
free sexe moviest
humour sexe gratuitt
sexe video freet
sexe gratuit hard interracial asiant
galerie porno gratuitt
gay porno video demot
actrice film pornot
sexe gratuit et hardt
sexe hard cradet
yasmine and pornot
video francaise de sexet
film porno yasminet
baiser lesbienne xxxt
sexe xxx videot
video clip sexe xxx porno gratuitt
sexe asiatique spermet
catalogue divx pornot
pps image sexe sexyt
extrait porno videot
divx porno gratuitt
yasmine lyon pornot
film de sexe francaist
jeu en ligne pornot
sexe asiatique gros seint
les photo porno du bresilt
video porno gratist
image porno simpsonst
demo virtuelle film xxx gratuit sans connexiont
sexe amateurt
video xxx defemme mure gratuitt
demo virtuelle film xxx
actrice porno nu
pps sexe perso
perso sexe amateur
sexe tres extreme
jeu sexe en ligne gratuit
sex porno film
photo arabe porno
video amateur porno
spanking lesbienne sexe
blog sur sexe
free xxx galerie updated daily
liste acteur porno
photo sexe hard xxx
galerie sexe porno
xxx and gratuit
mangas porno photo gratuite
sexe xxx girls video
porno arabe video
luna sex porno photo video gratuit
jennifer gargner sexy xxx
photo de sex et porno
photo gratuite de sexe de femme mature
sexe anal extreme
porno and gratui
pps sexe diaporama
photo porno anal
xxx gay photo
video webcam sexe
pipe porno xxx
porno video amateur
star porno photo
photo de gay porno gratuite
professeur sexe xxx
video porno et gratuit
femme hentai xxx
video adults xxx free
hard xxx black gratuit
extrait video porno gratuit
porno black anal
video asiatique et galerie sexe
sexe amateur gratuit perso
blog video amateur sexe
clip film porno gratuit
extrait free video xxx
jeu sexe online
xxx video
amatrice sexe belge
hentai xxx
gay porno poilu gratuit
video porno etudiante gratuite
sexe asiatique gratuit video
photo et dvd porno gratuit
arabe hetero porno
film mangas porno
sexe hot mom
image porno gratuite
video porno africaine
porno gratuit ejaculation anal
photo video sexe amateur gratuit
clip porno lesbienne
sexe crade jpeg
couple video sexe
sexe hardcore gratuit extrait
sexe nu photo
sexe porno mangas
devenir actrice porno
film x gay porno
dvd sexe lesbienne
forum sexe amateur
grosse marocaine beurette sexe
porno tres mature
cam and sexe
sexe image sexe
forum de discussion sur le sexe
animation video porno gratuite
sexe hardcore film
xxx video movie
girls sucking men porno video
demo porno gratuite
clip de film porno
sexe entre femme et homme
porno gay maroc
telechargement video porno amateur gratuit
sexe gratuit porno
couple libertin sexe photo
blog porno perso
photo porno et video gratuite
blonde xxx
sexe extreme allemand
sexe ala cam
image de film porno
femme mure sexe tres poilu gratuit
video hard xxx
clip and video and de and sex
deviant clip xxx
dvd xxx gay
free live sexe
image porno d homosexuel
amatrice et sexe et free
bulle actrice porno
video ultra hard sexe gratuite
extrait amateur porno gratuit
lesbienne porno francaise
rencontre sexe
porno gay amateur gratuit
ado xxx sexe video
annuaire sexe exhibitionniste
blog film porno
histoire porno bas masque
skyblog paris hilton sexe
photo sexe amateur contribution gratuite
sexe avec amateur
film sexe hard
sexe amateur gratuis
video sexe preview hard gratuit amateur perso
sexe bien poilu
black girls xxx
clip sexe gay
free xxx porn
sexe black gay gratuit
sexe star video photo gratuit
photo and porno and gratis
mature porno
xxx totalement gratuit
sex xxx hard photo gratuit
xxx shannen doherty video free
photo sexe masculin
muscle men xxx hard
sexe amateur extrait gratuit
photo sexe homme nu
demo video sexe gratuit
sexe photo femme
video de star xxx
annuaire de sexe totalement gratuit
top sexe fr
sexe mature and boy
galerie photo et sexe
pin up toon xxx
xxx anal sexe pictures
extrait video sexe grtuit
video jeune sexe
photo porno couple gratuit
sexe xxx trans
arabe sexe gay
sexe gay gratuit etranger
porno gratuit amateur
annuaire porno couple jeune
femme sexe video
xxx porn movies
xxx extrait transexe
sexe nipples porno
lesbienne sexe bite
pps sexy porno sexe
photo porno star
blonde xxx gratuit
sexe web cam tout gratuit
porno amateur.x gratuis
film de porno a telecharge gratuit
anal porno movies
sexe video anal
extrait video xxx son image gratuit
sexe image
gratuit xxx pic photo
download free movies porno mpeg
video sexe porno gratuit
image porno gratuit
free black porno picture
video porno des star de cinema
sexe vieille
free anal porno
chat cam sexe gratuit
photo gay sexe
rencontre sexe vendee
sexe vieille pute
jeu java sexe
lolita tgp xxx gratuit
actrice porno asiatique
xxx clip free
photo xxx gratos
sexe femme noir
sexe avec femme mure
archive sex xxx video
star photo sexe
sex lolita xxx
histoire sexe homme nu
porno actrice
femme experimentees sexe anal
sexe video extreme
video perso porno amateur
free sample video porno
web cam gratuite de sexe
photo professeur xxx
sex free porno
extrait film porno vieille femme
azzedine acteur porno
photo sexe bizarre
sexe mgp clip
jeu sexe gratuis
road sexe
photo porno de naine
photo porno de naine
anal sexe video
hard sexe photo gratuite
sexe tres crade
video sexe gratuit sans telechargement
gay porno gratuit perso
film et photo porno
video porno femme mure pauline
sexe rencontre amateur
xxx movies jenna
mangas gratuit sexe
jeu and de and sexe and gratuit
telechargement gratuit film porno
photo porno femme black banlieue
sexe film x gratuit marre faux site
histoire sexe cocu
chatte star sexe
video gay porno extrait gratuit
film porno gratuit anderson
mangas and sexe and hentai and extrait and gratuit
hard sexe porno
jeu porno sans inscription
video xxx sur vieille zt vieux bourgeois
sexe
sexe
sexe
sexe
sexe
sexe
sexe
sexe
sexe
sexe
sexe
sexe
sexe
sexe
sexe
Posted by kimi98
at May 28, 2007 11:38 PM