comment #1

Steven Kar says ...

At least his review of the movie made me crack a smile once or twice; unlike the entire 2.5 hour garbage that was Funny People.

comment #2

Terry McCarty says ...

Sounds like classic Rex. Not all that different from other bad reviews he'swritten over the decades.

comment #3

p.Vice says ...

You should check out Armond's review, which compares it rather fittingly to You the Living, probably the last close-to-great movie I've seen.

comment #4

admiralmpj says ...

Jeffrey, clearly not everyone liked Funny People as much as you. (I hated it.) Clearly not everyone thought it was "candor and emotional intimacy". (I can say that that was what Apatow was going for, but I thought he failed because he was out of his depth..but again, that's me).

But to go from saying nobody's right or wrong in these matters, but in the same paragraph to basically say "if you don't agree with this point, you don't know what you're talking about" is a little disingenuous.

Fine, you don't like Rex Reed's review. Can't we just stick to that?

comment #5

diarrhea treatment says ...

You should check out Armond's review, which compares it rather fittingly to You the Living, probably the last close-to-great movie I've seen.

diarrhea

comment #6

byanyother says ...

Knocked Up is a terrible film. Terrible.

comment #7

115thDreamer says ...

Wow, haven't seen the movie yet, but yes, Rex is a runaway train in that review...just vicious. It's one thing to dislike Seth Rogen, but to call him an "aberration"? That's kind of harsh, I think. And the two previous movies were "moronic"? I don't think so. T40YOV was on TV just the other day, and I ended up watching a good chunk of it again just for a larf. I mean, jeez, that review is so churlish it makes you seem like Ben Lyons in comparison, Jeff - :-).....

comment #8

byanyother says ...

Being compared the Farrelly brothers and John Waters is a huge compliment, though.

comment #9

Steven Kar says ...

So we have "Actionman" Vs. "Actionmam."

And now I see that we might have "p.Vice" Vs. "diarrhea treatment"?

comment #10

Abbey Normal says ...

Anyone who would so casually insult the great John Waters is not to be trusted on the merits of comedic film (or really any film at all).

comment #11

Rich S. says ...

Wow, that goes so far over the top it sounds like a parody of a Rex Reed review.

comment #12

Deathtongue_Groupie says ...

I think I can speak for every cinemaphile in the country when I say:

Who gives a fuck what Rex Reed has said about ANY movie???

The man is a caricature of an effete New York City snob who's greatest claim to fame is 10 seconds in the first Superman movie. That and being Mae West before a sex change.

comment #13

Gordon27 says ...

"truthfully alleged "director"?

That's the kind of line where he obviously spent way too much time on this; he was gonna just say " "director" " but then said, no, wait, *alleged* director... then went back and threw in a "truthfully" which, linguistically, makes no sense, but feels like a guy trying to sound smart piling gratuitious words in.

However:

"should have been dipped in hydrochloric acid in the editing lab"

That's a funny line. Even if it's the only one in that truthfully alleged "critic"'s review.

comment #14

BoshBarnetWonkyDonkey says ...

It's just not funny either. If you're going to pan something it has to be more imaginative than "This movie is as funny as infanticide". That's like a music critic saying "Her voice sounds like a cat being strangled." It's lazy cliched shit.

I bet he chuckled himself to climax when writing this dirge. What a wet fart.

comment #15

Gordon27 says ...

Glad to see him using "retarded" as an insult, though. I guess people would've complained if he said Schwartzmann was too gay.

comment #16

p.Vice says ...

I've got a ten spot on diarrhea being the new nom de plume of our good friend Glenn Kenny. He's an expert on the subject.

comment #17

Gordon27 says ...

Ok, one more...

He rips into every single member of the cast, not just for their performance in this, but for apparently everything they've ever been in... including Jason Schwartzmann, the one person in the movie who starred in a film which nobody will argue isn't great, even if they don't think it is... but Eric Bana gets a pass? That's so silly.

Also:

"criminally unfunny people feigning to be pros"

More bad writing; no matter what you want to say about Adam Sandler and Seth Rogen, it is 100% factual that they are professionals at comedy. A better case could be made that Reed is feigning to be a truthfully alleged "critic". (Incidentally, you pretend to be, you feign being... but, from this review, Reed obviously doesn't have the grasp of English that the average 15-year old netsurfer does; check the sentence where he flips a "to" and a "by" so that it makes no sense at all)

Also also:

"This is a waste of two and a half hours of my life that I will never get back again."

If you willfully go to this movie, despite wholly and completely hating '40 Year Old Virgin', 'Knocked Up', Adam Sandler, Leslie Mann, Seth Rogen, and Jason Schwartzmann, you lose any right to make the above-quoted criticism. You knew what you were in for -- it's not as if the ad lied (everything in his review is in the ad -- who can tell if he even saw the movie?), or hid the presence of all the people he hates so rabidly.

And, yes, he tries to deflect it by saying he's a critic, so he had to see it. But that's obviously bullshit -- I could name 10 obviously-bad movies off the top of my head from this year and be sure that Reed reviewed none of them.

comment #18

poseidon72 says ...

Percentage wise Rex Reed has probably given a negative review to 80% of all the films he's seen in his very long career as a film critic.

comment #19

Gordie Lachance says ...

I thought the whole point of people like Rex Reed and Armond White was to trash good movies so people like us would constantly talk about them and post links to their sites.

Is there something I'm missing?

comment #20

Phatang! says ...

Please don't lump Rex Reed in with Armond White! Reed is an idiot. White, while being a grouch, is pretty damn smart.

comment #21

Edward says ...

Rex Reed=Asshole.

comment #22

dinther says ...

Have to agree with Deathtongue. Why get so worked up about anything he says? Ever? Just ignore him. Don't click on his review. Remove whatever newspaper that sponsored him from your browser.

As with Bill Kristol or Dick Cheney or anyone who has never created anything or been accountable for anything, but who spouts off angry vitriol -- let him wither and die in his own bile.

The world has passed them by.

comment #23

Terry McCarty says ...

Meanwhile, Patrick Goldstein hopes the movie is as funny as Rex's review:
http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/the_big_picture/2009/07/rex-reed-on-funny-people-not-for-anyone-with-an-iq-above-40.html

comment #24

George Prager says ...

Do you think that either of them (White, Reed) has ever been on a date?

comment #25

Steven Kar says ...

I don't see what's so wrong about trashing Funny People, a profoundly unfunny, deeply flawed, turgid, languorous movie starring unfunny actors. After all, it is all about opinion, taste and preferences, and Funny People is hardly a masterpiece.

comment #26

Monument says ...

Steven you could really give Rex a run for his money, put your thesaurus away.

comment #27

Gordie Lachance says ...

I hate all Judd Apatows movies. I hate them so much I go see them before they open and then I make sure I'm the first person to post in any thread about them. I hate Judd Apatow so much I can't stop thinking / talking / writing about him and how unfunny his movies are.

There are so many more funny movies out there but I have no interest in them. No sir, I'm just going to keep checking back here to see if anyone's said anything positive about Judd Apatow so I can set them straight.

Does anyone know what Judd Apatow's next movie is? I mean I'm sure it will suck but I want to clear my schedule right now and try to get advance tickets. because I'm sure I'll hate that too. He's sooooo unfunny.

comment #28

Steven Kar says ...

Monument,

I was just looking for some attention.

comment #29

dixiedugan says ...

Isn't Rex Reed past his sell by date?

comment #30

creepingmalaise says ...

Rex Reed is still writing reviews? I though he ran off with Jim Nabors to live in Maui.

comment #31

sumo-pop says ...

He's always been a nasty piece of business. As a critic, I haven't taken him seriously since he panned Last Temptation Of Christ. So in other words, a long fucking time ago.

comment #32

DeeZee says ...

John Waters has talent...at costume design.

byanyother: Well, the Farrelies before that Paltrow/ Jack Black movie, anyway.

comment #33

DeeZee says ...

Oh, wait, I meant Me, Myself and Irene.

comment #34

Myles says ...

Yikes. Was Apatow the one who caught Reed shoplifting CDs or what?

comment #35

Glenn Kenny says ...

I wouldn't normally jump in under such circumstances, but I just want to assure p. Vice that as of this writing, I haven't even seen either "Funny People" OR "You The Living," although I look forward to each eventuality. Just to keep the record straight. Thanks.

comment #36

Marty Melville says ...

"John Waters has talent...at costume design."

Horseshit. Or poodle shit... or whatever breed that doggie was.

Waters has made some extremely funny movies... not an easy thing to do. And when manacled to a studio gig, he's shown some decent journeyman chops.

comment #37

COCO says ...

Rex is good at what he knows...me thinks he
might not appreciate the ''humor'' involved or.....
maybe the generational thing has fallen in the
forest and he did hear that.....meh.....popcorn
anyone?

comment #38

OtownRog says ...

Two extremes---Reed on the acrid side, Wells on the gag side.
Funny People doesn't warrant either end of the spectrum. Middling, indifferent, rambling, a bit unoriginal.
And if the MySpace product placement is an indicator, YESTERDAY's news. Will Twitter hurt or help it Friday night? guessing more hurt than help. I saw a sea of cellphone lights pop on at about the 100 minute mark.

comment #39

crazynine says ...

Wait a second, how is this possible?

I could have sworn that Rex Reed and Jeffery Wells were the exact same person. They look alike, they write alike, and when they hate something, they hate it full bore, no nuance, no subtlety, no charity.

I've read a dozen posts by Wells-- hell, this year alone-- that were just as vitriolic as what Reed just said there. Michael Bay, Steven Spielberg, Peter Jackson and countless random Americans with different politics/fashion/appetites get precisely the same treatment here, week after week.

But yeah, that Reed sure is vile, Mr. Pot.

comment #40

nike air force ones says ...

The nike air force ones would even have numerous refreshed editions which achieves almost a total of 800 million dollars annually as a revenue account. Our team here in BAK even mentioned once in our postings that Nelly even added something exciting to it by coming up with a song called the Air Force Ones as an expression of his love for the iconic product. Nelly, as a leading hip hop sensation made an amazing influence to the overall popularity standing of the Nike shoe model.