Great Film vs. Asinine Reaction

IndieWire’s David Ehrlich is trashing the finest, most exquisitely composed, most emotionally moving film I’ve seen thus far at Telluride ‘22 — Sam MendesEmpire of Light (Searchlight, 12.9). Olivia Colman is 100% locked for yet another Best Actress Oscar nom; handsome and gifted newcomer Michael Ward is also amazingly effective. Utterly exquisite Roger Deakins cinematography. Extrafine supporting turns by Colin Firth and Toby Jones.

Light will absolutely be Best Picture-nominated — I’ll make bets with anyone. I thought it might be some kind of woke interracial romance, but it transcends all that shit. I agree about Belfast but otherwise Ehrlich knows nothing…trust me! (And you can dismiss David Poland‘s reaction also,.)

There Is Only “Tar”

Today’s schedule: Sam MendesEmpire of Light at 1 pm (Herzog), Mary McCartney‘s’s If These Walls Could Sing at 4 pm (Sheridan Opera House), Todd FieldsTar at 6:30 pm (Herzog), and then Luca Guadagnino‘s Bones and All at 10 pm (Herzog).

No “Women Talking” Verdict Until Sunday

At the last minute I decided to bail on last night’s (6 pm) screening of Sarah Polley‘s Women Talking, an adaptation of Miriam Toews’ 2018 novel about eight Mennonite women confronting a horrific pattern of sexual assaults within their community. Because of the all-female ensemble factor (except for the allegedly wimpy Ben Whishaw character) and an allegedly gripping feminist current, Polley’s film is being hailed a Best Picture contender by a fair number of award-season sniffers (including Variety‘s Clayton Davis).

On the other hand THR‘s Scott Feinberg has derisively tweeted about the Telluride air being filled with “hyperbole”, a friend whispered to me last night that I’ll “hate it”, and another friend joked that Polley’s film is “strongly, almost hilariously anti-male.”

I’ll be catching it either Sunday afternoon or Sunday evening. If it’s good, I’ll say so but not because I’m down for #MeToo flicks as a general rule. Never trust the in-the-tank crowd. The only people who count when it comes to honest assessments in this realm are independent straight shooters, or persons of a rare stripe.

So instead of Women Talking I caught Ryan White‘s Good Night Oppy, which had been strongly recommended by a certain seasoned columnist. I’m not saying I was sold a bill of goods, but the columnist did oversell it. Oppy is a decent-enough, family-friendly NASA heart doc about two Mars rovers (Opportunity, nicknamed Oppy, and Spirit) Mars rover who explored Mars for nearly 15 years. It’s basically about parenting, and particularly the pride that sometimes comes with that. It’s a good film but calm down.


“Bardo” Certainly Swings for Fences

Sprawling, story-less, Fellini-esque, strikingly conceived (to put it mildly) and somberly meditative, Alejandro G. Inarritu‘s Bardo (or False Chronicle of a Handful of Truths), which I saw last night at 9 pm, is one motherfucker of an older man’s interior dream-trip epic.

Because it’s basically a series of Tony Soprano-ish dream segments, or so it digressively seemed to me…flicked with foreboding and dread and yet darkly amusing. And there’s no way Bardo qualifies as a comedy, by the way…glumly satiric is a better description.

And yet you can’t say that Bardo isn’t delicious — “intermittently brilliant” is how a friend put it — in terms of all the visual seductions and titillations and wild-ass whatevers. It’s a feverishly imaginative, inwardly-focused, interior-dialogue art film that never once shakes hands or even acknowledges the mundane aspects of life as most of us know or perceive them. It’s a dream-realm thing, top to bottom and into the vortex.

“Bardo” is a Buddhist term that means “transitional state between death and rebirth.” Hence the dream-stream.

Understand that the dreams of Silverio Gama (Daniel Giménez Cacho), a 50ish hotshot Mexican journalist and documentarian who, like Inarritu, has been living and thriving in Los Angeles with his family for the last 20-plus years…understand that Silverio’s dreams are somewhat darker and certainly more grandiose in a social-indictment sense than the more personalized and modestly-scaled dream sequences cooked up by Sopranos creator David Chase.

Inarritu’s dream trips are more imaginatively complex and cliff-jumpy and (here’s where the indulgent Netflix syndrome kicks in) big-budgety. All kinds of fragments and fantasies and social metaphors and projections of this or that, but most of it boiling down to “who am I and what am I doing?” as well as “fuck all the predators and cheapeners of this planetary existence that we’re all sharing” as well as an occasional “fuck me”.

There’s no debating the instant assessment that came out of the Venice Film Festival, which is that Bardo is Inarritu’s 8 1/2. There are other films in this self-examining, “I’m pissed off because I’m getting old and have run out of fresh ideas” fraternity — Bob Fosse‘s All That Jazz, Woody Allen‘s Stardust Memories, Paul Mazursky‘s Alex in Wonderland and (I’ll bet no one’s mentioned this one) Blade EdwardsThat’s Life! (’86).

Seriously — the Wiki synopsis of That’s Life! is 90% Bardo: “Harvey Fairchild is a wealthy, Malibu-based architect who is turning 60 and suffering from a form of male menopause. He feels aches and pains, real or imaginary, and seems unhappy with his professional and personal life.”

Bardo often delivers the same kind of long and occasionally mystifying head-trip cards (“intermittently brilliant” means now and then) that 8 1/2 does, but it’s also warmer and more family-embracing at times. (I was especially taken with Griselda Siciliani‘s performance as Silvero’s middle-aged wife.) Stardust Memories is tighter and more entertaining. It’s deeper and stranger than Alex in Wonderland. Portions of All That Jazz struck me as more filling and exciting and urgent than Bardo, I have to say. It’s better than Edwards’ film — I’ll definitely give it that.

And yet portions of Bardo are glorious. I loved certain scenes so much that I didn’t want Inarritu to cut away. The opening desert sequence (a shadow running and leaping and flying, and then falling back to earth) is a wow. There’s a magnificent dance-party sequence that goes on for I-don’t-know-how-long, but it’s so exuberant and crazy-good I got lost in it. Not to mention a sexual episode here and there that did the trick. Not to mention a knockout battle sequence + piles and piles of dead bodies.

Read more