Carter’s Tut-Tut Response to “Verses” Furor

On 3.5.89 an essay titled “Rushdie’s Book Is An Insult,” authored by former President Jimmy Carter, was published in the N.Y. Times. He condemned Ayatollah Khomeini’s “fatwa” — a decree calling for Rushdie’s murder — as “an abhorrent response,” but he also cut apoplectic Muslims a little slack.

Carter compared the Islamic outrage that greeted Rushdie’s “The Satanic Verses” to the lunatic conservative Christian fury provoked by Martin Scorsese’s The Last Temptation of Christ (‘88) — an accurate analogy in that both firestorms arose out of rank fundamentalist ignorance. Except Carter said that he half-sympathized with (or at least understood in an emotional Christian-bedrock sense) the anti-Temptation mob.

Carter’s basic point was “try to see things from the Muslim perspective…if you do that their rage will become half-understandable ” His implication was that Rushdie had only himself to blame for poking the hornet’s nest.