Daniel Petrie's "Lifeguard" ('76) Finally Doesn't Satisfy
December 9, 2025
Before Last Night's 45th Anniversary...
December 9, 2025
Now That Netflix Is Finally Streaming “Jay Kelly”
December 8, 2025
Bottom–lineHFPAstatement: “Eff you, Jon Chu…not good enough.”
While at the same time they’ve handed a Best Film Comedy / Musical nomination to OneBattleAfterAnother, that all-singing, all-dancing laugh riot from Paul Thomas Anderson, the Stanley Donen of the 2020s.
Seriously — fraudulent or self-satirizing inclusions in the GG comedy / musical category have been a running joke for a long time, but apart from Sean Penn’s played-straight erection scene, there isn’t so much as a single sincere snicker in the whole film..,not a one.
What this means, of course, is that Hamnet will most likely win the Best Drama prize. But it’s not a shoo-in because of the unrelenting grief-and-grime factor during the first 85%. Which means that HEfave Sentimental Value has a reasonable shot.
Put another way, we don’t want Joe Schmoe ticket buyers to feel any kind of tingly excitement when OBAA starts winning big-time.
We want them to scratch their heads and wonder what the fuck is going on here, etc.
Remember how badly most of you guys felt when Everything Everywhere All At Once won everything in ‘22? How you howled and screamed and repeatedly punched the refrigerator when Jamie Lee Curtis won for Best Supporting Actress? Well, grim up and get ready for a repeat.
Because we not only hateyou, but we want you to really, truly and fully comprehend that.
Thank God, at least, that Sinners and the dragon-fingered Cynthia Erivo will almost certainly be getting the bum’s rush.
At least SentimentalValue ‘s Stellan Skarsgard snagged a richly deserved supporting trophy. OBAA’s Teyana Taylor? Not so much. Aside from Sean Penn’s Col. Lockjaw, she blew no one away…be honest.
…but it was certainly the most fun to write, and remains to this day the most fun to re-read:
Earlier this afternoon I suffered through most of Mascha Schilinski’s Sound of Falling (Mubi) and I want credit, dammit, for toughing it out for just short of two hours. (It runs 149 minutes.)
A hellish, multi-chapter, visually dreary, narrative hop-around from the perspective of a few suffering women and young girls at different times during the 20th Century, Sound of Fallingbrings the grim and the soul-drain in the usual suffocating ways.
You could say that the soft, muddy, under-lighted cinematography is meant to inject the same shitty, misery-pit, lemme-outta-here feeling the women and girls are experiencing at every turn. Sure, I’ll buy that.
Is Schilinski an auteur — a feisty, willful, go-for-it filmmaker with a persistence of artistic vision and a stylistic stamp all her own (albeit a stamp that brings you down, down, down)? Yes, she is that.
Does her film have something to say? Yep. It’s saying that 20th Century farm women in northern Germany were miserable as fuck, and that the men were either smelly pigs or abusers or both, and that most of them smoked and a few had massive pot bellies.
Sound of Falling doesn’t make you think about dying before your time, but it does prompt thoughts of escaping the mortal coil early on.
On top of which I was sitting in the Grand Lumière balcony, scrunched between two women and with no leg room at all, and my thighs and calves were stuck in a kind of purgatory, suspended between numbness and screaming pain.
But I didn’t leave for the longest time. I wanted to but I couldn’t be the first balcony-sitter to bail. I said this to myself — “no quitting until a couple of viewers go first”.
So I hung in there with the patience of Job, waiting for some intrepid soul to man up and bolt the fuck outta there, but nobody did for the first…oh, 100 minutes or so.
And then a woman got up and walked. And then another. Thank you, sisters, and thank you, my sweet Lord…glory be to God!
I stood up with my bag and retreated to the main walkway, and then decided to watch from a standing position. And then another person threw in the towel. And then another. And then a trio of Zoomers left at the same time. Hey, we’re really livin’ here!!!
I’ve never felt such wonderful kinship with strangers as I did at that moment.
Variety’s Guy Lodge, the bespectacled king of the Cannes filmcrit dweebs, has totally raved about Schilinski’s punisher.
I respect Lodge’s willingness to drop to his knees and kowtow to a feminist filmmaker who has the chutzpah to subject viewers to a drip-drip gloom virus, but at the same time I think he’s either left the planet or had simply decided to praise this fairly infuriating film no matter what.
Average Joes and Janes, trust me, are going to hate, hate, hate this exactingly assembled, artistically pulverizing tour de force.
This is a woke hit piece. Listen to the eerie music. Seriously, listen to it. It’s from an elevated horror film about witches and warlocks living in the woods.
On top of which the AI narrator pronounces Darien as DAIRien rather than the commonly used DahriENN.
And then The Tender Bar doubles down by changing the identity of a wealthy Westport white girl named Sydney, whom Moehringer fell in love with during his time at Yale and who represents the unattainable ideal for a working-class kid from Manhasset. Clooney has changed Sydney from a blonde, Daisy Buchanan-like character with a small nose, ample breasts and whiter-than-white parents (her father is described by Moehringer as Hemingway-esque) into a beautiful woman of color (Briana Middleton) and her parents into an interracial couple (mom is played by Quincy Tyler Bernstine).
The first word that came to mind was “again?”
This is yet another example of virtue-signaling, inclusion-mandate casting, and particularly Clooney and producers Grant Heslov and Ted Hope wanting to groove along with the ethos of progressive woke Hollywood.
I grew up in Wilton and Westport, and I personally knew of one couple of color (opera singer Betty Jones, a friend of my mom’s, and her husband) and heard about no interracial couples at all. That’s not to say there were none, but if they existed in the Wilton-Westport-Weston region they were, like, waay under-the-radar.
Oneword: mandals. Men of substance and conviction have never, ever worn them…period. Indian moccasins, tennis sneakers, unlaced brown suede bucks, even penny loafers…any of these would have been tolerable.
The year was 1954, by the way. Cooper was only 53, and yet he looked 60ish and his hair was half gone. When did he start wearing rugs? He must have been wearing one when he shot High Noon in ‘52. He had double the amount of hair in that adult western.
I knew that the Critics’ Choice bowl-lickers would deny Deliver Me From Nowhere a Best Picture nom because it flopped critically and commercially. Because they were unimpressed along with everyone else, but also (primarily?) because the CC gang knew that dismissing it would be politically safe.
I also knew they’d snub Jeremy Allen White‘s portrayal of Bruce Springsteen.
But I figured they’d at least hand Jeremy Strong a Best Supporting Actor nom for playing Springsteen manager Jon Landau, largely because it was an intelligently rendered perf and wholly believable, and because Strong is widely respected. Nope!
Anthony Zerbe: I was just reading your play. I liked a lot of it. I don’t like the main character though. This Marine. Sounds like a real jellyfish. I guess you’re supposed to like him because he’s against the Marine Corps. Is that it? Michael Moriarty: Something like that. AZ: Why doesn’t he do something? Go over the hill, refuse an order. I couldn’t sympathize with a character like that. MM: Not everyone did. AZ: The Marine in the play, that supposed to be you? MM: No. AZ: Maybe a little? MM: Maybe on some level. AZ: Uhn-huh. You know what I think, “on some level”? I think you’re the kind of wise-ass cocksucker that writes a tearjerk play against the Marines and then turns around and smuggles a shitload of heroin into this country. MM: I deny that. And no more literary conversation until I call my lawyer. AZ: You mean Ben Odell? No Commie lawyer’s gonna help you now.
In my humble opinion the most accurate term is neither “unhoused” or “homeless.” The correct term, boiled down, is almost certainly (and I truly regret the statistics on this) “hopeless” and more precisely “bums.”
Posted on 3.14.12: What would David Huddleston‘s Jeffrey Lebowski say about this? “Get a job, sir!”
But it’s a job that lowers my dignity, Mr. Lebowski. I may be homeless for the time being but I have a soul and I have rights and I have a dream that one day I’ll be back on my feet, earning my way with a steady gig, paying taxes, driving my own car and living in a nice apartment.
“And how do you think you’re going to get back on your feet?,” Lebowski would reply. “By complaining about your dignity to news reporters? Show some of the enterprising spirit that made this country great by doing whatever you can short of breaking the law to earn whatever you can, and by saving as much as you can until you can afford to start living in a decent place. Life isn’t easy, son. But I’ll tell you one thing for sure, and that’s that the bums will always lose! Condolences!”
In January 1976, Esquire magazine ran a photo-spread piece called “Bums.” They went down to the Lower East Side and found a few winos, and brought them uptown and fed them and cleaned them up and dressed them in the best elegant-smoothie clothes that money could buy, and took their picture in a studio. Some of the bums looked pretty good and pretty happy (at least while they were being photographed). They were definitely being exploited, these guys, but would they have been better off if Esquire hadn’t offer them money to take part in this little charade?
An “annoyingly whimsical ditty — notable solely for its key change from D major to F sharp major”? Maybe so, but (a) it settled my soul as I listened last night in the car and (b) I dearly love that chord change!