True Topanga Canyon story: It was around ’84, maybe ’85. I was platonically chummy with Kathryn, a whipsmart production executive, a woman with a good heart who suffered no fools. She was sharing a sizable home in Topanga Canyon with a couple of others, and every so often would invite friends over on a Saturday or Sunday. I attended a couple of these schmoozers. Filmmakers, publicists, producers, writers, production veterans…late 20s to late 30s.
A day after one of the get-togethers Kathryn called to say that a female friend of hers liked me, and that I should give her a ring. Let’s call her Laura. I wasn’t sure who she was, and Kathryn was reluctant to offer any specifics other than the fact that Laura and I had briefly spoken at some point.
I finally persuaded Kathryn to offer a vague physical description, and it came to light that Laura was a nice but less-than-dynamically attractive 20something who was on the pudgy side. The weight issue was what jarred my memory.
As I respected and trusted Kathryn, I figured I could level with her as our chat would go no further. So I told her Laura wasn’t my type and that I wasn’t exactly into plus-sized women — no offense.
Kathryn felt free to be candid also, and so a split second after I said “plus-sized” she said, “You bastard!” As in “how dare you refuse this intelligent, good-hearted, high-quality woman just because she’s not rail-thin?”
I thought I was being a good guy for two reasons. One, I was being honest with a friend and two, I wasn’t interested in having sex just because it was more or less being offered to me. I wanted intimacy only with women I was genuinely aroused or intrigued by, and preferably both.
That wasn’t how Kathryn saw it. She knew and cared for Laura, and apparently over the previous couple of years the poor woman had experienced some hurtful, frustrating or otherwise unsatisfying relationships, and here I was doing nothing to alleviate her distress or otherwise brighten her day.
I said I was sorry but what did Kathryn want me to do, lie or pretend?
Imagine if the situation had been reversed. Imagine if I’d found Laura attractive and a male friend of mine who knew her had called and said that I’m smitten and would like to go out with her, etc. Imagine if Laura had told my friend “well, I’m very flattered but Jeff isn’t my type…no offense but I’m just not interested, much less aroused.”
How would it have been if my friend had replied, “You bitch! His feelings will really be hurt by this!” Different rules, different standards.
Read more