Totally Erroneous “Tango” Reporting

A forthcoming limited series about the making of Bernardo Bertolucci‘s Last Tango in Paris is in the works from CBS Studios and Greg Silverman’s Stampede Ventures. Variety‘s Naman Ramachandran reports that the series, written by Jeremy Miller and Daniel Cohn, will span the 18 months before, during and after the production of Tango, and will be told through the lens of those at the center of the events — stars Maria Schneider, Marlon Brando and Bertolucci.”

Ramachandran gets it dead wrong, however, by stating that Bertolucci “admitted” that the film’s infamous anal rape scene film “was not consensual” as far as Schneider was concerned. I repeat — DEAD WRONG. Bertolucci never said that the scene itself (which was scripted) was non-consensual — the only surprise or non-consensual aspect was the use of butter as a lubricant.

In a 12.3.16 Variety piece by Seth Kelley, Bertolucci said that “I had been, in a way, horrible to Maria because I didn’t tell her what was going on” — i.e., by not telling her about the butter. And yet, the late director added, he didn’t regret shooting the scene. “I didn’t want Maria to act her humiliation, her rage. I wanted Maria to feel, not to act, the rage and humiliation. Then she hated me for her whole life.”

Two days after the Kelley interview, on 12.5.16, Bertolucci clarified to Variety‘s Nick Vivarelli:

“I would like, for the last time, to clear up a ridiculous misunderstanding that continues to generate press reports about Last Tango in Paris around the world,” Bertolucci stated. “[Three] years ago at the Cinematheque Francaise someone asked me for details on the famous butter scene. I specified, but perhaps I was not clear, that I decided with Marlon Brando not to inform Maria that we would [use] butter. We wanted her spontaneous reaction to that improper use [of the butter]. That is where the misunderstanding lies.

“Somebody thought, and thinks, that Maria had not been informed about the violence on her. That is false!”

Bertolucci explained that “Maria knew everything because she had read the script, where it was all described. The only novelty was the idea of the butter.”

The sexual penetration of Schneider by Brando was simulated, of course.

4K “Horse Soldiers” in Early ‘22

Hollywood Elsewhere is perfectly satisfied with a 2011 MGM Bluray of John Ford’s The Horse Soldiers — good color, exceptional detail, 1.66:1 aspect ratio — so I’m not sharing any particular excitement over Kino Lorber’s forthcoming 4K version, which will emerge early next year.

Ford scholar Joseph McBride, who recently recorded a commentary track for the KL disc, has posted the following on Facebook:

“This Civil War film is an example of what a great director can and can’t do with a weak script. The film has sublime imagery by Ford and cinematographer William H. Clothier and many moving vignettes but is burdened with plot contrivances and other story and production problems. “

[HE interjection: The film is not burdened with a “weak script” — it’s fine. Punctuated by several memorable sequences (futile Confederate attack on Newton Station, Union soldiers retreating when attacked by boys from a local military school) and fortified with fine performances top to bottom.]

“Ford was devastated at the end of location shooting and lost much of his already tenuous interest in the film when a beloved member of his Stock Company, stuntman Fred Kennedy, died doing what should have been a routine horse fall.

“I interviewed people involved in the filming, including a witness to that event, while researching my biography SEARCHING FOR JOHN FORD and did additional research for this commentary on one of the director’s somber late works, an especially grim look at that war. It’s always a privilege to be asked by Kino Lorber to comment on films by my favorite director.”

HE commentary:

Saluting David Guilpil

Hollywood Elsewhere joins the mourners of legendary Australian (Aboriginal) actor and dancer David Guilpil, who has passed from lung cancer at age 68.

A symbol of indigenous pride and a man of great meditative silence, Guilpil’s best-known or most striking performances were captured in Nicolas Roeg’s Walkabout, Peter Weir’s The Last Wave, Crocodile Dundee (original + sequel), Philip Noyce’s Rabbit Proof Fence and Ten Canoes (‘06).

Noyce: “For tens of millions the world over, David was the living embodiment of Australia’s 100,000 year First Nation culture. He taught us all so much.”

Son of Red and White

Posted on 7.9.08: HE commenter Burmashave: “Anybody ever think about James Dean playing Jesus if he’d lived, and how fucking crazy that would have been?”

There’s a distinct similarity factor between Rebel Without a Cause‘s James Dean and King of KingsJeffrey Hunter. Both films were directed by Nicholas Ray, of course, so in a sartorial fashion Ray did sorta kinda cast Dean in his Bible movie. He did this by having Hunter wear a facsimile of the iconic red jacket and white T-shirt get-up that Dean wore in Rebel.

Variety critic Todd McCarthy reminded me this morning, in fact, that “Ray dressed Hunter in a robe of exactly the same shade of red as Dean’s Rebel jacket.”

The idea of Christ wearing a red robe had already been established in The Robe and Demetrius and the Gladiators, but think for a moment about the ludicrousness of a dirt-poor Jesus of Nazareth wearing a red cloak with a perfect white T-shirt garment underneath. It’s as if they had Gap and Banana Republic shops in old Jerusalem, and Jesus and his disciples occasionally shopped there.

What if J.C. had hired a fashion consultant? “As you know, Nazarene, plain red works fine on every occasion, but — stop me if I’m overstepping — you need to present an extra stylistic distinction, something that says ‘this guy is special’ and not just some, whatever, shepherd or olive farmer or whatever, if you follow my drift. That’s why a white undergarment is such a good idea. And it comes with white briefs in case, perish the thought, you’re ever crucified, because the Roman guards will let you keep the briefs on. Or at least, they have with my other customers.”

“Everything you say about King of Kings is right,” McCarthy wrote about my 7.8 posting, “but to me the most compelling aspect of the film it how political it is. The first whole section of the picture details the political situation in Judea at the time with almost documentary-like attention, and the script’s great and provocative gesture is to present Jesus and Harry Guardino‘s Barabbas as parallel revolutionaries — Jesus of a religious stripe and Barabbas as a political outlaw, which makes the ending ironic.

“In defining the major Jesus films of the ’60s-70s period, it’s fair to say that Stevens’ The Greatest Story Ever Told is the Protestant version, Zeffirelli’s Jesus of Nazareth is the Catholic version, Pasolini’s The Gospel According to St. Matthew is the Marxist version and King of Kings is the Zionist version.

“Of course Hunter is physically far too fair (and note the shaved armpits at the crucifixion), but he still manages to achieve a poignant purity as things move along. The score is one of Rozsa’s very greatest and crucial to covering over various narrative lurches and shortcomings. And, by the way, there are no known 70mm prints, so you can’t blame the Cinematheque for not delivering one.””

Moreno Apparent “WSS” Standout

Jeremy Wein attended Sunday’s SAG screening of Steven Spielberg‘s West Side Story, and has tweeted that Rita Moreno, who plays “Valentina,” the widow of “Doc”, the elderly drugstore owner played by Ned Glass in the ’61 version, is “the heart of the whole thing.”

Dan Gaertner conveys a similar report:

World of Reel ‘s Jordan Ruimy passes this along:

Good for Moreno, but this seems a bit curious. A supporting character with a big emotional scene in the latter half overwhelms the contributions of the leads (Ansel Elgort, Rachel Zegler, Ariana DeBose, David Alvarez)?

Similar reaction to 1961 version: “Natalie Wood, Richard Beymer, Russ Tamblyn, Rita Moreno and George Chakiris were good enough, but Ned Glass knocked it out of the park.”

James Rocchi…Adieu

I’m trying not to sound all performance-arty about the sad, sudden passing of former movie critic and film festival get-around guy James Rocchi, who was 53. Felled by a heart attack. He wasn’t a “friend” but I certainly liked and admired him during the Rocchi peak years (late aughts to mid teens), and he seemed to enjoy or at least tolerate my routine for the most part. (He often addressed me as “Doctor Wells.”). I’m running around Manhattan as we speak but I’m very, very sorry for James’ loss, and ours. He was a total gentleman, and he always dressed impeccably.

Arguably Finest Kitchen-Sink Poster Art

I’ve been watching Lindsay Anderson’s This Sporting Life (‘63) off and on for 20+ years, or since the dawn of the DVD/Bluray era. Easily my all-time favorite “throwing up in the kitchen sink” drama, and certainly one of Richard Harris and Rachel Roberts’ greatest roles.

Denys Coop’s black-and-white cinematography is heavenly, and yet I’ve never gotten hold of an HD-streaming or Bluray version.

The kitchen sink genre was otherwise known as England’s “free cinema” movement. Most know this, but perhaps not all.

Lying Summaries

Sorry, Air Mail headline-writer, but I don’t agree.

At best, Peter Jackson’s 468-minute Get Back doc is occasionally “beautiful” and “poignant”; more often it’s intriguing (look…Linda Eastman is actually chatting with Yoko Ono!), a comfortable hang, subtly confrontational, diverting, undeniably historic, necessarily repetitive, sloggy, friendly, amusing, a tad boring, etc.

And don’t tell me what I need or don’t need to feel while watching it. I can figure that stuff out on my own, thanks.

Crowds Love “Gucci” Hoot Factor

In a 11.27 Air Mail essay, designer Tom Ford laments the blend of soap opera and SNL-ish satire that, in his opinion, dominates Ridley Scott’s House of Gucci. HE to Ford: You were there so your voice radiates authority, but (a) movies be movies (b) the paying audience I saw it with ate that shit up, especially the flamboyant performances of Lady Gaga and Jared Leto.

Those Dynamic “Girlfight” Vibes

Before the Sundance Film Festival woked itself to death, it was the indie pathfinder and trailblazer — the greatest-ever springboard for American indie cinema. And in my 24 diligent years of covering that January celebration (’95 to ’18), one of the most exciting Sundance premieres was Karyn Kusama‘s Girlfight on 1.22.00.

A great boxing flick, a first-rate relationship drama and the film that launched Michelle Rodriguez, it won the festival’s Grand Jury Prize and the Best Directing Award in dramatic competition. Produced for $1 million, Girlfight‘s distrib rights were bought by Screen Gems for $3 million.

I saw a proud and tough feminist film, and one that could really connect with Latinas and women of color along with indie film fans.

Girlfight opened eight months later (9.29.00) and promptly flopped. Latinas and women of color stayed away in droves. After a five-week run it had tallied a total domestic haul of $1,565,852 plus a lousy $100,176 overseas. I’ve never understood why this happened. I’ll bet that a fair percentage of HE readers never even saw it.